Friday, June 13, 2014

The Words on the Holmes Murder Castle

Some debate has come up lately about the cryptic words that appear in some later photos of the HH Holmes "Murder Castle." No photo has emerged that's really clear enough to read it, but there were some words carved into the turret at one point. They would not have been present in any version of the castle Holmes ever saw; they were added when the top two floors were rebuilt after the 1895 fire.

Here's a shot of the castle from the late 1930s, shortly before its destruction, with a zoom-in on the turret:


It's hard to read, and had possibly been damaged by the late 1930s, but earlier shots make it clear that the word was "block," and that another word had been on the left at one point. 

Here's the clearest shot I have, taken from a 1914 article on the death of Patrick Quinlan (the guy I always describe as "the Igor of the Murder Castle"). The picture was probably old; a murkier, cropped version of what I think is the same photo was in the Chicago American in 1905. During this period, the castle had a stylish pointed turret that I think might have been removed after a fire in 1907:


And a zoom-in on the turret from this shot:


That the second word is "Block" is quite clear here - for buildings this size to be called "____ Block" was quite common at the time. But what' the first word?

A comment I had in 2009 or so said that the building used to say "Campbell Block," and that "Campbell" was later removed. Holmes used the name HS Campbell for most of the legal dealings used for the building. However, by the time it was rebuilt, he no longer had the title or mortgage to the building. At the time of the Aug, 1895 fire, the building (and its insurance) was held by the Frank Chandler Co, which owned dozens of properties around the city and around Englewood; Chandler spoke to the press a bit during the investigation, and after the fire (when it was noted that the paperwork regarding the title and the insurance were a huge mess).  They already seem to have held some title to at least a portion of the place as early as 1889, when the name "Frank Chandler" starts showing up in paperwork related to the lot. 

Anyway, the grainy photo may be from about 1905, which is also when Chandler seems to have had to sell off all the properties. 

Several real estate listings from 1904 and 1905, when the properties were on sale, refer to the building as "Chandler Block." Like this Trib classified from 1905:


Now, this brings in some mysteries of its own. The building was three stories, and 45x100 is smaller than most measurements (maybe the candy store in the rear of the first floor, and the extended space behind it, were lopped off when it was rebuilt? The fire started in the candy store).  However, it's definitely the Castle building - that was the exact address prior to the 1909 renumbering, and a couple of Englewood papers from the same period talking about the sale specifically refer to it as the old "Holmes Castle." 

Now, the weird thing to me is that in that early 20th century shot, it does look a bit more like "Campbell" than "Chandler" to me! The digitization isn't that clean; it'd be better if I could get a proper microfilm scan of that issue of the Ogden Standard's pull-out magazine, but I'm not about to take a trip to Ogden, Utah to find one!  The most likely scenario here is that it's just hard to read the pixelated version, but that it said "Chandler Block," and the name "Chandler" was chipped off after Chandler no longer held it, presumably by some buyer who never got around to adding a new name. 



Keeping in mind, of course, that this is not a version of the building Holmes ever laid eyes on. The fire in August, 1895 during the investigation didn't burn the whole building to the ground, but the top two floors WERE removed and rebuilt. They looked very different before, as seen in the surviving photo:


Of course, there's a whole LOT more castle stuff in the newly expanded ebook:







7 comments:

awfingl said...

The last picture looks like an extra floor was added at the top. Maybe some kind of atrium, or rooftop penthouse?

Anonymous said...

The last picture looks like an extra floor was added at the top. Maybe some kind of atrium, or rooftop penthouse?

Adam Selzer said...

Yeah, there may have been something like an atrium up there; his wife's uncle had a story about him being eager to show up the roof. The third floor itself was sort of a later edition; I think there were just two of them for the first couple of years.

Unknown said...

I've seen some other photos that show the letters "Campbell Block" pretty clearly. I've always thought that the walls/facade on the upper stories were still intact after the 1895 fire and that only the interior was gutted. The early photo, I believe, simply shows the building unfinished with framing underneath for the bays and upper facade. So, the top of the turret with any building name or cornice wasn't there yet at the time of the photo. I've seen accounts of the building's construction that indicate it took a long time to finish, and that the third story was added a year or two later, after the lower two floors were done. That would make sense if the original building with two stories (and Holmes' office area) was complete sometime in 1890 and the upper floor was added about 1892 in anticipation of housing visitors for the World's Fair.

Adam Selzer said...

Thanks, Unknown! It's not widely known that the building survived the fire at all, really, but even less so that the top two stories were replaced after Holmes was gone. But the tearing down of the top two actually made the press - the was an article in the Chicago Daily Inter Ocean when they were removed a few weeks after the fire. A very small notice, but it's a good source.

The top two floors had been largely vacant since the earlier fire in 1893, at the end of the "fair era," except for a couple of tenants. Businesses on the first floor stayed open. The building was barely habitable, though, even before the fire.

The early photo that goes around dates to 1895, just before the fire and after Holmes was out of the place. The easiest way to tell that is that Dr. Robinson's name is on the awning over the drug store. He took it over from Holmes (then sold it during the investigation).

It did take quite a while to finish, to the extent that it ever WAS finished. The first two stories came close, then Holmes borrowed a few grand from Dr. Maurice Lawrence and his wife to add the third to take advantage of the fair. Dr. and Mrs Lawrence lived on the second floor, and continued to be for quite awhile, even though Holmes never paid them back - there's a lawsuit on file in the state archives from when they tried to sue him. I may do another post of the lawsuit data soon, but it's hard to pick and choose - the guy got sued a LOT!

none name said...

https://frankzumbach.wordpress.com/category/comment/page/20/
here's a photo of t he turret. it says "chandler"

Adam Selzer said...

So there is! Wish the guy would say where the heck he found it (or any of them, including the ones he got from here).

LinkWithin

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...